Are MCA leads really exclusive, or resold to other brokers?

By David Walker-Dobson, Founder, Tentt Finance · Updated

Are MCA leads really exclusive, or resold to other brokers?

Some MCA leads are exclusive, but many are not. Real-time leads are often sold to several buyers, and most leads are later resold as aged leads or data. A lead is only exclusive if the vendor contractually commits to one buyer, ever. The only prospects nobody else can contact first are businesses you reach yourself, such as through Tentt Finance outreach under your name.

Key takeaways

  • "Exclusive" often means exclusive for a time window, not forever.
  • A lead is a business owner who asked for funding. Data is a list of businesses that did not ask.
  • Warning signs of resold leads: owners who say they were called already, very low prices, and no consent proof.
  • Get exclusivity, the resale window and returns in writing, then test before you scale.

What is the difference between MCA leads and MCA data?

MCA leadMCA data
What it isA business owner who asked about fundingA list of businesses that match filters
IntentExpressed: filled in a form or took a callNone expressed
Typical price$10 to $200+ per leadCents per record
Contact rulesConsent proof matters for calls and textsCold outreach rules apply
CompetitionDepends on how many times it was soldAnyone can buy the same list
ExamplesReal-time inquiries, live transfers, full submissionsUCC lists, aged lists, business directories

Vendors blur the two. An "aged lead" is usually an old inquiry that has been sold many times, which makes it closer to data than to a lead. A "UCC lead" is data: a business with a public financing filing, not a business that asked for money.

How do MCA leads get resold to multiple brokers?

There are four common ways the same business owner reaches several buyers:

  • Shared tiers. The vendor sells the same real-time lead to a set number of buyers, often three to five, and says so.
  • Ping-post and affiliates. Many vendors buy leads from affiliate networks that offer the same lead to several marketplaces before it reaches you.
  • Aging. After an exclusive window, often 30 to 90 days, the lead moves to an aged tier and is sold again, sometimes many times.
  • Repeat applications. Owners who need money fast fill in several forms on several sites, so even an honestly exclusive lead may be talking to other funders.

None of this is hidden in good vendors' terms. The problem is when "exclusive" is used loosely, without saying for how long or from which source.

What are the warning signs of recycled MCA leads?

  • Business owners say they have already had several calls today.
  • Many owners have already funded or have several open positions.
  • The price is far below the market for the lead type: exclusive real-time leads for a few dollars.
  • The vendor cannot show a consent record, such as a TrustedForm or Jornaya certificate, or the page where the owner applied.
  • The vendor will not put exclusivity and the resale window in writing.
  • Disconnected numbers and wrong contacts run well above the vendor's returns allowance.

Ask your setters to log one question on every first call: "Have other funders contacted you about this request?" A month of answers tells you more than any vendor claim.

What should you ask an MCA lead vendor about exclusivity?

  1. How is each lead generated, and can I see the form or ad the owner responded to?
  2. Is this lead sold to anyone else, now or later? If later, after how many days?
  3. Do you buy leads from affiliates or other vendors, and are those leads exclusive to you?
  4. What consent record comes with each lead?
  5. What is the returns policy for bad numbers, duplicates and owners who say they did not apply?
  6. Can I run a small test batch before committing?

Get the answers in the order form or contract, not just on the sales call. Our guide to MCA lead types compares what each type should cost.

Which MCA lead vendors sell the most recycled leads?

There is no public, reliable ranking of vendors by resale rate, and claims in vendor-written "best of" lists should be treated with care. Brokers on forums such as deBanked share experiences, but individual results vary with timing, lead type and how fast the team calls.

The practical answer is to measure it yourself. Run two or three vendors through the same 30-day test, log the "already contacted" answer and funded rate for each, and keep the vendors whose leads fund. Plug the results into the lead cost per funded deal calculator.

How can a broker get prospects nobody else has?

The only prospects guaranteed not to be shared are the ones you create yourself. That means referral partners, your past clients, and direct outreach to businesses that fit your buy box before they fill in a form anywhere.

Tentt Finance white-label outreach for brokers and ISOs contacts every business in your buy box every 60 days, by email under your brokerage's name. When an owner replies, the reply came to your inbox, so no other broker received it. It is a monthly retainer, month to month, with pricing on request.

Frequently asked questions

Are exclusive MCA leads really exclusive?

+

Only if the vendor commits in writing that the lead goes to one buyer and is never resold. Many "exclusive" leads are exclusive for a set window and then sold again as aged leads.

What is the difference between MCA leads and data?

+

A lead is a business owner who asked about funding. Data is a list of businesses that match filters but have not asked, such as UCC or aged lists.

How many times are MCA leads resold?

+

It varies by vendor. Shared real-time leads usually go to three to five buyers, and aged leads can be resold many more times. Ask each vendor for its exact policy.

Are aged MCA leads worth buying?

+

Sometimes, for teams with dialers and cheap labor. Aged leads have usually been called by many funders, so funded rates are low. Compare them on cost per funded deal.

Does Tentt Finance sell MCA leads?

+

No. Tentt Finance runs white-label email outreach for lenders, brokers and ISOs on a monthly retainer. Replies go to the client alone. Tentt Finance is not a lender.

Own your market instead of renting leads.

Pick a time for a 30-minute call. We size your market, check your territory is open and tell you what it would cost.

Book a call

Related