Pay per lead vs retainer: which should a loan broker choose?

By David Walker-Dobson, Founder, Tentt Finance · Updated

Pay per lead vs retainer: which should a loan broker choose?

Pay per lead bills only for leads delivered, usually $15 to $200 each, but those leads are often shared with other buyers. A retainer bills a fixed monthly fee for the work. Ad-based agency retainers add ad spend and multi-month minimums. An outreach retainer like Tentt Finance includes everything, runs month to month and makes every reply exclusive.

Key takeaways

  • Pay per lead moves the risk of a failed campaign to the vendor, but you share most leads with other buyers.
  • Ad agency retainers are the riskiest: a fee plus your ad budget plus a 3 to 6 month minimum.
  • An outreach retainer prices the work, not the lead, so every reply is yours alone.
  • Compare every model on cost per funded deal over the same 60 to 90 days.

How do the three pricing models compare?

Price ranges from vendor price pages and broker guides reviewed in November 2026.
Pay per leadAd agency retainerOutreach retainer
What you pay forEach lead deliveredAgency time, plus your ad budgetThe outreach program
Typical price$15 to $40 shared, $25 to $200 exclusive, $40 to $200+ live transfer$2,000 to $3,000+ a month before ad spendMonthly, all in; pricing on request (Tentt Finance)
Ad spendNone on your booksYours, often thousands a monthNone
CommitmentPer orderOften 3 to 6 monthsMonth to month (Tentt Finance)
Who else gets the prospectOften several other buyersNobody, if the funnel is yoursNobody: the email came from you
If it failsYou pay nothingYou still pay fee and adsYou pay that month's fee
Ramp-upDaysWeeks to months of testing2 to 3 weeks of inbox warmup
Who owns the assetThe vendorCheck the contractYou: domains, data and replies

How does pay per lead work for MCA and business loan brokers?

Pay per lead is the simplest model. A vendor generates inquiries from business owners, usually through ads and web forms, and sells each one at a fixed price. Shared real-time leads usually cost $15 to $40, exclusive leads $25 to $200, and live transfers $40 to $200 or more. Aged records cost cents because they have already been sold and called many times.

The broker's main advantage is low risk. There is no monthly fee and no ad budget, and a test batch of 25 leads is often possible. If the vendor's campaigns fail, the vendor carries the loss.

The main drawback is competition. Most pay-per-lead inventory is sold to more than one buyer, so the business owner hears from several funders and brokers within minutes. Funded rates on shared leads are low, and the deal goes to whoever calls first with the best rate. Our guide to MCA leads explains each lead type in more detail.

How does a lead generation retainer work?

A retainer is a fixed monthly fee for work, not for a number of leads. Two very different services use the same word, and they carry very different risk.

Ad agency retainers run paid ads and landing pages for you. Funders Collective, a broker lead vendor, puts the going rate at $2,000 to $3,000 or more a month before ad spend, with 3 to 6 month minimums common. The ad budget sits on top, so the real commitment over a quarter can run to tens of thousands of dollars whether or not the campaigns work.

Outreach retainers contact the businesses in your buy box directly, by email under your name. There is no ad budget. The fee covers the data, the inboxes, the copy and the follow-up. The prospects are businesses that fit your criteria, not people who filled in a form on someone else's site, so nobody else receives the same reply.

What about rev share or pay per funded deal?

Some lead sources take a share of the commission on each funded deal instead of charging per lead or per month. Rev share looks risk-free, because you only pay when a deal funds. In practice the share comes out of your best deals for as long as the arrangement runs, and the source usually controls the relationship with the business owner.

Rev share suits brokers with almost no cash for marketing. It suits brokers with steady volume less well, because a fixed cost per deal is usually cheaper than a percentage once volume grows. If you take a rev share offer, get the split, the term and who owns the merchant relationship in writing.

Who carries the risk in each model?

Pay per lead puts the generation risk on the vendor. The broker carries the conversion risk: shared leads that do not answer or have already funded elsewhere.

An ad agency retainer puts almost all the risk on the broker. You pay the fee and the ad budget during the testing months, and a failed campaign is your loss.

An outreach retainer splits the risk. You pay a fixed monthly fee, but there is no ad budget and no long minimum, so the most you can lose is one month's fee. The first replies come after the 2 to 3 week inbox warmup, which is why a fair test runs for a full 60-day cycle.

How do you compare pay per lead with a retainer?

Convert every option to cost per funded deal. Take everything you spent with a source over the same 60 to 90 days, including team time, and divide it by the deals it funded.

An illustrative example, not a benchmark: 120 shared leads at $25 cost $3,000. If 3 fund, that is $1,000 per funded deal. For a monthly outreach retainer, divide the fee by the deals it funds in the same way. The difference is that none of those owners heard from another broker first. Your own rates will differ, so plug them into the lead cost per funded deal calculator.

Ask every vendor two questions before you compare: how many other buyers receive each prospect, and who owns the data and the relationship if you stop.

When does each model make sense?

  • Pay per lead: you are new, cash is tight, and you need calls this week. Start with a small test batch and track funded rate per vendor.
  • Ad agency retainer: you fund 30 or more deals a month, have a long horizon and want to own a paid acquisition funnel.
  • Outreach retainer: you want a steady flow of exclusive conversations from businesses that fit your buy box, under your own name, without an ad budget.
  • Rev share: you have no marketing budget at all and accept a lower margin on every deal.

Many brokers combine models: a small pay-per-lead budget for this month's volume and an outreach program that builds next quarter's pipeline. Tentt Finance white-label outreach for brokers and ISOs is built for the second job.

Frequently asked questions

Should an MCA broker pay a lead gen agency a monthly fee or pay per lead?

+

Pay per lead is safer when cash is tight because you only pay for delivery, but most leads are shared. A monthly fee is worth it when it buys exclusive conversations and has no long minimum. Compare both on cost per funded deal.

Is rev share better than pay per lead?

+

Rev share only charges on funded deals, which suits brokers with no budget. As volume grows it usually costs more per deal than a fixed price, and the source often controls the merchant relationship.

Why do lead gen retainers have a bad reputation?

+

Many ad agency retainers bill a fee plus ad spend with 3 to 6 month minimums, so brokers pay heavily during testing even if campaigns fail. Retainers without ad spend or long contracts carry much less risk.

How much does Tentt Finance cost?

+

It is a monthly retainer based on your buy box size, month to month with no setup fee, and pricing is on request. Every retainer includes data, white-label inboxes, copy and follow-up. Tentt Finance is not a lender and does not sell leads.

How long before a retainer produces deals?

+

For email outreach, new inboxes need 2 to 3 weeks of warmup before sending at volume, so judge results over a full 60-day cycle.

Own your market instead of renting leads.

Pick a time for a 30-minute call. We size your market, check your territory is open and tell you what it would cost.

Book a call

Sources

Related